The hallowed halls of the White Tower played host to one of the most contentious and rule-breaking trials in recent Aes Sedai history as Nynaeve alMeara underwent her official testing for the shawl. Documented in Chapter 20 of Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson’s Towers of Midnight, the evaluation pushed the boundaries of traditional White Tower customs, sparking intense debate among the Sitters, challenging the authority of the Amyrlin Seat, and forcing a critical re-evaluation of institutional rigidity on the eve of the Last Battle.
Main Facts of the Trial
Nynaeve alMeara’s progression to full Aes Sedai status has long been anticipated given her immense innate potential in the One Power, her instrumental role in cleansing saidin, and her defeat of the Forsaken Moghedien. However, her evaluation before the assembled Sitters and Amyrlin Egwene al’Vere was anything but routine. Escorted by the newly appointed Mistress of Novices, Rosil of the Yellow Ajah, Nynaeve immediately signaled her refusal to conform to conventional subordination. Rejecting the customary placement of the great serpent ring on her left ring finger as an Accepted, she asserted her status as a raised sister, a perspective ultimately validated by Rosil.
The trial within the arch ter’angreal—a legendary artifact designed to test a candidate’s mental fortitude, emotional control, and dedication—demanded the completion of one hundred distinct weaves in exact sequence while maintaining absolute composure. Candidates are typically instructed to approach designated star markers without hurrying or hesitating and are forbidden from channeling until reaching the marker.
However, Nynaeve’s deep familiarity with Tel’aran’rhiod, the World of Dreams, uniquely equipped her to subvert these spatial and operational limitations. Faced with a gauntlet of harrowing psychological simulations—including volcanic eruptions, rampaging Trollocs, burning orphanages, and threats against her home in the Two Rivers and her husband, Lan Mandragoran—Nynaeve repeatedly broke protocol. She ran when instructed to walk, channeled outside of permitted zones, and ultimately unleashed the forbidden weave of balefire to combat the illusion of Darkhounds in a simulation of the Blight.
Chronology of Events
The sequence of the trial unfolded through a series of escalating psychological hurdles and procedural breaches:
- Pre-Trial Assertion: Nynaeve declines to wear her ring as an Accepted, successfully persuading Mistress of Novices Rosil that she will not undermine the authority of the Amyrlin who raised her.
- The Formal Inquiry: Before the assembled Sitters and Amyrlin Egwene al’Vere, Nynaeve declares she has come to prove her worthiness for the shawl she already possesses, drawing immediate disapproval from the leadership.
- The Gauntlet Begins: Bound by a weave of Spirit administered by Saerin to reinforce memory and protocol, Nynaeve enters the arch ter’angreal.
- Escalation and Rule-Breaking: As the trials progress from natural disasters to attacks on loved ones, Nynaeve’s frustration mounts. She rejects arbitrary constraints, runs toward markers, channels prematurely, and utilizes balefire during the final simulation involving her husband, Lan.
- Post-Trial Debate: Emerging physically and emotionally exhausted, Nynaeve is healed by Tower sisters while a fierce political debate erupts among the Sitters regarding her numerous rule infractions and use of dark magic.
- Narrow Confirmation: By a razor-thin margin of four votes to three, the assembly grants Nynaeve the shawl, conditioned upon a night of contemplation.
- Bonding Resolution: Following the confirmation, Nynaeve confronts Myrelle at the Black Tower encampment, successfully claiming the Warder bond of Lan Mandragoran to restore her husband’s connection and secure her personal equilibrium.
Supporting Data and Institutional Context
The White Tower testing process is designed to filter candidates based on strict adherence to decorum, emotional detachment, and unquestioning obedience to Tower laws. Historical records within the institution emphasize serenity and institutional preservation above individual pragmatism. Yet, Nynaeve’s trial data reveals systemic friction between traditional orthodoxy and the pragmatic demands of a changing world.
According to post-trial assessments by Sitter Saerin and Amyrlin Egwene al’Vere, Nynaeve committed multiple infractions:
- Pacing Violations: Running through simulated environments rather than maintaining a measured, calm walk.
- Unauthorized Channeling: Bypassing restrictions on the use of the One Power prior to reaching designated markers.
- Forbidden Weaves: Employing balefire, a catastrophic weave capable of unravelling the fabric of time and reality, within the ter’angreal.
Despite these violations, mitigating factors heavily influenced the final vote. Egwene al’Vere noted that Nynaeve’s extensive experience in Tel’aran’rhiod effectively rewired her cognitive interaction with simulated environments, making strict adherence to the ter’angreal’s artificial rules nearly impossible for her. Furthermore, political pragmatism prevailed: denying the shawl to a channeler of Nynaeve’s stature—who holds geopolitical ties as the Queen of Malkier and has spearheaded revolutionary Healings—would have set a disastrous precedent for the White Tower’s credibility.
Official Responses and Internal Discord
The aftermath of the trial exposed deep ideological fractures within the White Tower leadership.
Saerin vehemently defended Nynaeve against what she termed "downright vengeful" testing by the Sitters, accusing the examiners of imposing unprecedented and malicious hardships on the candidate. This sentiment was countered by hardline traditionalists like Barasine of the Red Ajah and Rubinde of the Green Ajah, who argued that Nynaeve’s failure to demonstrate proper Aes Sedai decorum invalidated her candidacy.
Barasine maintained a rigid stance, declaring that Nynaeve had fundamentally failed the standards of composure required of the Sisterhood. Conversely, Egwene al’Vere—operating under the constitutional constraint of having no vote as Amyrlin—navigated a delicate diplomatic path. Privately, Egwene acknowledged that the tests involving the Two Rivers and Lan were intentionally harsh, designed to preempt accusations of favoritism while testing Nynaeve’s ultimate loyalties.
When pressured by Saerin to forswear the use of balefire permanently, Nynaeve offered a flat refusal. She argued that the impending Last Battle at Shayol Ghul may necessitate any tool required to secure victory for the Light, prioritizing global survival over institutional oaths. This pragmatic utilitarianism drew sharp rebukes from traditionalists but resonated with the broader reality of the apocalyptic threat facing the continent.
Broader Impact and Implications
Nynaeve alMeara’s successful, albeit controversial, attainment of the shawl marks a pivotal turning point for the White Tower. For millennia, the institution has cultivated an air of untouchable authority, often prioritizing its own bureaucratic self-preservation and emotional detachment over direct engagement with the populace—a dynamic that earned them the title "Servant of All" while simultaneously distancing them from everyday human suffering.
Nynaeve’s critique of this insular culture underscores a broader philosophical crisis within the leadership. By asserting that institutional titles are secondary to immediate humanitarian necessity and personal integrity, she challenges the foundational mythology of Aes Sedai superiority.
Furthermore, the resolution of her personal arc—culminating in the recovery of the Warder bond with Lan Mandragoran—cements her unique position as a bridge between traditional power structures and independent, practical action. As the White Tower prepares for the ultimate confrontation at Shayol Ghul, the integration of non-conformist veterans like Nynaeve into the formal hierarchy signals that the institution must adapt to survive, replacing rigid dogmatism with flexible, reality-driven leadership.

