As the theatrical run of Focus Features’ Elsinore officially commences and the critical precursor circuit approaches, the race for the Academy Award for Best Actor is entering a highly competitive phase. Andrew Scott, widely anticipated to secure his first career Oscar nomination, faces a formidable field, standing as a primary challenger to perceived frontrunners John Malkovich for Wild Horse Nine and Matt Damon for The Odyssey. Historical precedent offers two distinct roadmaps for how Scott might navigate this high-stakes campaign: one relying on Elsinore securing a coveted Best Picture nomination, and the other detailing how a potential top-tier snub could still be surmounted.
The Current Landscape and the Precursor Challenge
Scott steps into the 2024–2025 awards season with significant industry momentum, buoyed by acclaimed performances in recent years across television and film, including Fleabag, Sherlock, All of Us Strangers, and 1917. In Elsinore, Scott portrays Ian Charleson, a biographical and emotional transformation depicting the real-life actor battling AIDS while attempting to mount a final, definitive stage performance as Hamlet.
Despite his established profile, Scott enters the race positioned similarly to previous contenders who started behind the narrative curve. The Best Actor category frequently rewards veterans riding overdue narratives or anchors of stronger overall Best Picture contenders. Currently, John Malkovich benefits from a legacy narrative reminiscent of industry titans who accumulated career goodwill over decades. However, unlike past seasons where a single dominant contender locked down the race early, the wider competitive slate—featuring heavyweight contenders like The Odyssey, La Bola Negra, Dune: Part Three, and You Can See Everything—creates a fragmented race where traditional frontrunners may face resistance.
The Best Picture Correlation: The Eddie Redmayne Blueprint
To evaluate Scott’s potential path to victory, industry analysts frequently look back at the 2014 Best Actor race, which provides a direct template for an underdog actor overcoming an established veteran. In 2014, Michael Keaton was heavily favored to win the Academy Award for Best Actor for his performance in Birdman, a film that ultimately claimed the Best Picture prize. Keaton swept much of the early precursor season, backed by a powerful career narrative and the immense strength of a Best Picture winner.
However, Eddie Redmayne ultimately clinched the Oscar for his physical
transformation as Stephen Hawking in The Theory of Everything. Redmayne’s victory relied heavily on two crucial factors: a late-season surge driven by victories at the BAFTAs and the Screen Actors Guild (SAG) Awards, and the crucial backing of a Best Picture nomination. The Theory of Everything secured five Academy Award nominations, establishing a baseline of institutional support that kept Redmayne viable despite losing the majority of early regional critics’ prizes.
For Scott, replicating Redmayne’s trajectory requires Elsinore to secure a nomination in the Best Picture category. Over the past sixteen years, statistical precedent heavily favors Best Actor winners whose films are also recognized in the top category, regardless of whether those films are competitive for the ultimate win. If Elsinore performs strongly on nomination morning—potentially echoing The Theory of Everything by overperforming in key categories—Scott would possess the necessary structural backing to challenge Malkovich or Damon on Oscar night. Furthermore, industry observers note that while Redmayne was a relative newcomer to the top tier of awards contenders in 2014, Scott enters the race with broader international name recognition and critical acclaim, potentially easing voter familiarity.
Navigating a Best Picture Snub: The Brendan Fraser Precedent
Should Elsinore miss out on a Best Picture nomination, Scott’s campaign is not automatically disqualified. A more recent historical parallel exists in the 2022 Best Actor race, won by Brendan Fraser for his performance in The Whale.
Much like Scott’s current position, Fraser faced a preseason favorite originating from a Searchlight Pictures production—in that case, Colin Farrell for The Banshees of Inisherin—alongside a major summer blockbuster lead in Austin Butler for Elvis. Furthermore, The Whale missed out entirely on a Best Picture nomination, a hurdle that historically eliminates most acting contenders. Fraser managed to overcome this deficit through a combination of factors: a powerful personal comeback narrative, robust industry goodwill, and secondary technical nominations that provided a safety net.
The Whale secured a Best Makeup and Hairstyling victory, alongside a Best Supporting Actress nomination for Hong Chau. For Scott and Elsinore, a similar lifeline could materialize if the film secures key acting or craft recognition—such as a supporting nomination for Olivia Colman—even if it misses the Best Picture lineup. Fraser ultimately capitalized on his momentum by capturing the SAG Award for Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading Role, bypassing his lack of a Best Picture slot just as previous victors had defied conventional wisdom.
Comparative Analysis of Campaign Trajectories
Analyzing these historical templates reveals distinct strategic advantages and potential pitfalls for Scott’s campaign as the season progresses:
- Early Precursor Performance: Eddie Redmayne was nearly shut out during the early critics’ awards season before rallying at the BAFTAs and SAG. Conversely, Brendan Fraser accumulated a substantial tally of critics’ prizes before securing the industry’s ultimate stamp of approval at SAG. Scott is expected to land somewhere in between, likely capturing major televised precursors such as the Golden Globe for Best Actor in a Drama and a strong showing with BAFTA, while potentially sharing the regional critics’ spread.
- Narrative and Transformation: Both Redmayne and Fraser underwent significant physical and emotional transformations to portray real-life or deeply vulnerable characters. Scott’s portrayal of Ian Charleson aligns with this tradition of transformative, high-stakes drama that traditionally resonates strongly with the Academy’s acting branch.
- Studio Support and Coattails: Focus Features’ positioning of Elsinore mirrors past campaigns that relied heavily on individual powerhouse performances. Whether the film can drag itself into the Best Picture race like The Theory of Everything or rely on singular acting strength like The Whale remains the central question for Oscar prognosticators.
Implications for the 2024–2025 Awards Race
As precursor nominations loom, the fate of Andrew Scott’s Oscar campaign hinges on how Academy voters respond to Elsinore as a whole. If the film captures the imagination of voters and secures a Best Picture slot, Scott can leverage a traditional path to victory modeled on Eddie Redmayne’s 2014 triumph. If the film underperforms and misses the top category, Scott must execute the playbook established by Brendan Fraser, relying on industry-wide affection, acting branch strength, and crucial precursor momentum to break historical trends.
Regardless of which trajectory ultimately unfolds, the historical parallels demonstrate that early-season frontrunners are frequently vulnerable to late-stage surges. As theatrical screenings expand and voting bodies begin casting their ballots, Scott’s performance in Elsinore positions him as one of the most closely watched variables of the cinematic awards season.

